Support CELTUA CELTUA Blog Facebook Twitter

The Center for the Enhancement of Learning, Teaching, and University Assessment

Assessment: Assessment Basics

RUBRICS

A rubric is a guide that describes the criteria that will be used to score or grade an assignment. A rubric identifies the traits that are important and describes the levels of performance (e.g., unacceptable to excellent) within each of the traits.

Rubrics can:

  • Clarify for student the expectations for an assignment.
  • Reduce bias and improve consistency in scoring.
  • Communicate to students both their strengths and weaknesses.
  • Assist faculty in determining which (student) skills are well-developed and which skills require improvement.

Below you will find a variety of sample rubrics. Some of the rubrics provided are still "works in progress." Furthermore, in order for a rubric to be useful, it should be tailored to meet the needs and outcomes of the specific course or program. Therefore, please feel free to adapt the sample rubrics to meet your specific needs. If you need help designing a rubric, please contact Cecilia Shore.

General/Templates

Rubistar
Rubistar is a free tool intended to help faculty design rubrics. Rubistar allows users to identify general content areas for the rubric as well as specific learning outcomes. Rubistar then provides appropriate rubric categories based on the learning outcomes identified.

Template for a Descriptive Rubric (PDF)
Adapted from: Stevens, D. D., & Levi, A. J. (2005). Introduction to Rubrics: An Assessment Tool to Save Grading Time, Convey Effective Feedback and Promote Student Learning. Sterling, Va: Stylus Publishing, LLC. The sample text is from the Elaborated Washington State University Critical Thinking Rubric.

Template for a Rating Scale Rubric (PDF)
Adapted from: Stevens, D. D., & Levi, A. J. (2005). Introduction to Rubrics: An Assessment Tool to Save Grading Time, Convey Effective Feedback and Promote Student Learning. Sterling, Va: Stylus Publishing, LLC.

AAC&U’s Valid Assessment of Liberal Undergraduate Education Project

The VALUE project involves creating assessment mechanisms based on multiple expert judgments rather than standardized tests. Over the last two years, over 100 experts in various disciplines have generated rubrics for all of the Liberal Education and America’s Promise (LEAP) learning outcomes. Those rubrics are now available on the website. The rubrics are intended for institutional level assessment and can be adapted to fit particular contexts (including courses or programs).

Critical Thinking

Assessing Critical Thinking (ACT) Project at Miami University's Liberal Education office
Faculty participants worked in teams of 3-4 to design and conduct an assessment of critical thinking in one of their courses. As part of this project, faculty developed and used a critical thinking rubric. The ACT webpage provides critical thinking rubrics that have been adapted to fit a variety of disciplines.

Critical Thinking/Integration (PDF)
This rubric, which closely models the Washington State Critical Thinking rubric, includes additional criteria for comparing and contrasting multiple perspectives. (Social Sciences)

Criteria for Assessing Creativity Process (PDF)
Lindstrom, L. (2006). Creativity: What is it? Can You Assess it? Can it be Taught? The International Journal of Art and Design Education, 25(1),53-66.

Elaborated Washington State University (WSU) Critical Thinking Rubric (PDF)
This rubric, which was adapted from the WSU rubric, provides more elaborated explanations of the criteria associated with the WSU rubric.

Science Critical Thinking Rubric (PDF)
This rubric is a modified version of the WSU Critical Thinking Rubric and was adapted to assess critical thinking in the Natural Sciences.

Steps for Better Thinking/Washington State University (WSU) Critical Thinking Rubric (PDF)
This rubric, which is based on the WSU Critical Thinking Rubric, applies a cognitive development perspective to students' critical thinking. The rubric identifies students' critical thinking skills as they move from lower-level to higher-level thought processes.

Washington State University (WSU) Critical Thinking Rubric (PDF)
The WSU critical thinking rubric identifies seven specific critical thinking outcomes (e.g., "Identifies and summarizes the problem/question at issue") and related criteria. Additional details on the WSU Critical Thinking Project can be found on their website.

Reflection and Action Rubrics

Action Project (PDF)
This rubric provides guidelines and criteria for conducting an "action project," in which students are expected to design and implement an intervention for a specified problem. (Social Sciences)

Action Proposal (PDF)
This rubric provides guidelines and criteria for conducting an "action project," in which students are expected to identify a problem and design an intervention for the problem. (Social Sciences)

Application Paper (PDF)
This rubric provides guidelines for a paper in which students must apply use theories to analyze real-world issues and problems. (Social Sciences)

Research and Literature Reviews

Literature Review (PDF)
This rubric was designed to provide guidelines for conducting and writing a literature review. (Social Sciences)

Research Proposal (PDF)
This rubric provides criteria for assessing a research proposal. (Social Sciences)

Research Project (PDF)
This rubric provides criteria for assessing the final report for a completed research project. (Social Sciences)

Scientific Inquiry Rubric (PDF)
Developed specifically for the Natural Science Departments, this rubric assesses students' ability to engage in scientific inquiry (e.g., to collect, analyze, and reflect upon data).

Collaboration Rubrics

Rubric to Evaluate the Quality of a Rubric

Contact Us:

317 Laws Hall • 551 E. High St., Oxford, OH 45056 • 513-529-9266 • celt.miamioh.edu

© 2014 Miami University | 501 East High Street | Oxford, Ohio 45056 | 513-529-1809
Equal opportunity in education and employment | Trouble viewing this page? accessibility@miamioh.edu
Privacy Statement | Miami University is a smoke-free environment.